PROJECT: 3D For Everyone – Results
- At June 11, 2008
- By Neil Creek
- In Projects
6
Congratulations to the Winners
Public Choice : Niall O’Callaghan |
Judge’s Choice : David W. Kesner |
3D For Everyone has been the most successful project on this blog so far, with 42 entries, 114 votes on the submissions, and a very successful first ever sponsorship of the project. Having the sponsors, Loreo, provide free 3D viewers to all entrants was wonderful, and the post I wrote about 3D photography for DPS was dugg and sent a LOT of traffic to this blog and the project.
It’s obvious to anyone, that 3D photography is accessible to anyone with a camera, and the variety of appropriate subjects is enormous. 3D brings a new dimension to photography, figuratively and literally. There are many creative possibilities to be had by taking advantage of the unique properties of stereo photography. I hope that we’ll see more and more stereophotography from you all, and the rest of the world going forward.
A big congratulations to David W. Kesner, the winner of the first ever prize offered on this blog, the Loreo 3D Lens-in-a-Cap. Unfortunately, David’s site seems to be undergoing an upgrade, and when I tried to contact him to ask what kind of mount he would like his 3D lens to have, his email bounced. David, if you are reading this, please get in touch with me at neil@creek.name so that we can arrange to have your prize sent to you.
Judges’ Comments
The judges worked together to choose the winner by consensus, however, there were many other favourites. In addition to the winner, the judges each selected a favourite entry to be awarded an honorable mention. Below you can read the judges comments on the winner, as well as their selected honorable mentions.
![]() |
Winner: David W. Kesner |
Cody: It’s a wonderfully cluttered affair, isn’t it? But it’s so much fun to look through all of the antiques and knickknacks. I liked the image before getting my cross-eyes on, but it’s a real treat in 3D. I’ve always been partial to second-hand stores and old junk, so maybe that influenced my decisions, but it doesn’t take away from this great shot. | |
David: A nice blend of color and clutter. | |
Naomi: This picture instantly grabbed my attention. It looked interesting before viewing in 3D, but once in the 3D zone, it was fantastic! There is so much to see in this picture and you just want to hang around to look in all of the nooks and crannies to see all of the knick-knacks and treasures. There is just so much depth to it. I don’t know if it’s museum real shop or an illustration, but there is something magical and intriguing about it. It is a perfect specimen for 3D. |
![]() |
Honorable Mention: Michael Comerford |
Cody: Despite the focus issue, to me this is the most impressive example of 3D because of the great use of DOF. It really shows the effects of the technique all the way through the image and I don’t even mind that there’s a very narrow window of focus, hardly one at all. |
![]() |
Honorable Mention: Dominic Portain |
David: I thought I was looking through my childhood Viewmaster. The composition and visual balance of this scene is just beautiful. I love the leading line of the road in the background leading right up to the church with the church in just the right position of the composition – the top right 1/3. Notice too, as the eye moves from foreground to background we get a repeat of color in the rooftops repeated in the foreground, mid-ground and background. All the inner voices of this scene – composition, color, balance, and beautifully executed 3D make it a top choice. |
![]() |
Honorable Mention: Roger Harris |
Naomi: This early on submission has been a favourite of mine. It is picturesque and uses the 3D effect fantastically. Also, by masking around the flowers so they “pop” out, this has extended the 3D effect which I think is a clever technique. I also like the non-traditional shape of the image. |
Submissions
Below are the full list of submissions for the project, including the photographers name and link. Where provided, I have linked to the photographer’s site or blog, but in most cases the links point to the photo itself, wherever it was stored. I would like to encourage you to go and comment on the original photos you like best, if that option is available. There is some terriffic stereophotography here!
|
|
|
Josh Thompson |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Alexey |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Public Vote Results
And here are the results of the voting.
[poll id=”3″]
A couple of final points
To those of you who have not yet received your Pixi 3D viewer, I have some bad news and some good news. The bad news is that they have currently run out of stock of the viewers, so there will be a delay getting them to you. The good news is that the reason for the delay is that the versions sent out so far were late prototypes, and the factory is now producing the brand new, improved production version of the Pixi 3D viewer. So when you receive your 3D viewer, it’ll be an even better one.
To those who have already received their viewers, Loreo tell me that you will be sent another, final production version of the Pixi 3D viewer. How cool is that? You get two free viewers!
I want to take this opportunity to thank the generous sponsors of this project, Loreo. Coming soon to this blog you can look forward to an in-depth review of the 3D Lens in a Cap. Also coming soon will be a survey that I would like all participants to complete, all about your experiences with the Pixi 3D viewer. Loreo are still keen to get your feedback, so it would be great of you to help out.
One final observation: I don’t know if this means anything or not, but when submitting their entry with their postal address for shipping the Pixi 3D viewer, only ONE out of the two-dozen or more American participants included their country in their address! On the other hand, every single one of the dozen or so European participants included theirs… Curious no? :)
Next Project
It’s a bit late coming, but I know you don’t need a full month to get involved with a project, right? Well for the June project, I’m returning to a favourite. The Iron Chef Photogrpahy project in March was very popular, so I plan to do a new one every three months. Watch the blog for a post very soon all about the new Iron Chef Photography project. This month:
Iron Chef Photography: A Shoe
PROJECT: 3D For Everyone – Judges and Extension
- At May 22, 2008
- By Neil Creek
- In Projects
0

Have you been having fun taking and looking at 3D photos? I’m thrilled with the submissions that I have received for the 3D For Everyone project so far! And there’s been quite a bit of 3D attention directed at the blog in the last day.
DPS post
Last night (midnight my time), Darren of Digital Photography School posted my newest post there, which features some of the best 3D photography from around the net. He titled it 9 Crazy Cross Eye 3D Photography Images and How to Make Them, far more interesting than my original title “3D is Back!” :) Since then I’ve had a huge influx of traffic to the blog, mostly from people new to 3D reading the instructions for how to see 3D images. I’m sure some of the popularity of the post is due to a 3D photo of a rather fetching young woman in her undergarments – the source of some unfounded controversy in the comments in the post.
The post has been picked up on some of the social network sites, so I was hoping you all might be able to do me a favour, and help it along a little, by helping to spread the word. If you are registered at Digg, would you please digg the post. If you use StumbleUpon, could you stumble it. If you have any other favourite social networks, I would greatly appreciate it if you could help spread the word through them as well!
Date Extension
I’m sure that there’s going to be a few more entries to the project from these new visitors, and I look forward to seeing them. The due date is very close however, so to give these new folks a bit more of a chance to get their photos to participate, I’m extending the due date for the project by two days to May 26th. Check here for the time in your local time zone.
Announcing the Judges
It is with great pleasure that I can announce the three judges who will be responsible for evaluating your work and choosing the winner, who will get the Loreo 3D Lens-in-a-Cap from our generous sponsors, Loreo. Cody has blogged about his participation in the project at his blog. David has blogged about my 3D photography before. Naomi is well known to the readers of this blog, and has some skills that will being a unique perspective to the judging. You can read more about them below:
Cody Redmon is a native and current resident of Montana who fell in love with landscapes at an early age. Growing up in a rural area gave him the access to explore his interest and grow his techniques, while visiting some of the most beautiful areas of the United States’ northwest and southwest regions. As a photographer, his goal is to capture the beauty of a scene and present it in a manner which conveys emotion. He has a deep respect for the wilds and is pleased to present to you scenes and vistas from the back reaches of Montana, Idaho, Wyoming and Utah. He maintains a personal blog of current works at Cody Redmon – Photoblog, and has additional signed and numbered, limited edition prints on his personal website, CodyRedmon.com.
David Ziser is a professional photographer from the metro Cincinnati area. He concentrates mostly on weddings and family portraits. To relax, he enjoys landscape and fine art photography as well, and puts quite a bit on energy into both when he has a bit of spare time on his hands.
Naomi Creek has been a keen artist since childhood, always eager to try her hand at anything that could express her creativity. Working as a graphic designer for the last 20 years, she has had the pleasure of sourcing beautiful imagery for use in brochures and advertising material. She loves nature and animals and it is with this passion that brought her to meet her husband, Neil Creek whilst he was observing the starry skies through his telescope. Naomi is enjoying sharing in Neil’s photographic journey and spends many hours with him appreciating the wonder of nature, future technology and the possibilities that lie around the corner. Her hobbies include anything artistic, like jewellery making, cooking or painting.
Dont forget that every entry gets a free Pixi 3D viewer, and the winner gets a Loreo 3D lens for their DSLR!

If you would like to participate in 3D For Everyone, then please visit the project page. There you will find full details about the project, instructions on how to see and take 3D photos, and the submission form through which you can submit your entry.
PROJECT: 3D For Everyone – Submissions
- At May 11, 2008
- By Neil Creek
- In Projects
17

Submissions for the May photography project, 3D For Everyone, are starting to come in, and they’re looking great! After a suggestion from a reader, I have decided to offer both cross-eye (as described in How to See 3D Photos) and parallel view versions of the submitted entries. To view the entry with your preferred method, simply click the links below the image. The “X” links to the cross-eye view, and the “U” links to the parallel view.
Voting
Submissions are closed and voting has begun for the public choice winner. Please choose our favourite of the 3D photos below. Please only vote if you can see the 3D effect of these images so that you can judge them as stereophotos, and not just ordinary photos.
The voting will continue for the rest of the month, and will finish at midnight on May 31st AEST – check here for the time in your zone.
You can view all the submissions below, and vote via the form below them. (Note: Due to a clerical error, there is no entry #15)
Submissions
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Vote Now!
[poll id=”3″]
Prizes

I will be sending the postal addresses of the entrants to Loreo a few at a time, so that I don’t spam their email. Once Loreo have received your details, they will soon ship to you your Pixi 3D viewer. The viewer will be shipped fromLoreo’s head offices in Hong Kong, and they tell me that typical shipping time is 2-3 weeks. Depending on how busy Loreo are, where you are located, and any other conditions, it may take some time for your viewer to arrive. Your patience is appreciated.
Reader Q: 3D photography of moving subjects
- At May 10, 2008
- By Neil Creek
- In 3D
0
Occasionally I get email or comments or Flickr messages that I think might be best answered via a blog post. Other people may be interested in the question and my best efforts at an answer. I received this question through Flickr the other day, and asked Pepe’s permission to answer it here. As part of 3D month, here’s a query about moving subjects in 3D photography:
The Question
I have just read your discussions on ‘How to see’ and ‘How to take ‘3D photos. My sincere congratulations. I am going to recommend then in my site at Flickr.
Only one thing I don’t quite understand: you said, apparently wihout exceptions, that nothing can move between shots in ‘Disadvantages’ in ‘How to take 3D photos’, but evidently, in your examples you have many shots even of people practicing sports. Perhaps this is a contradiction or I didn’t understand you well. I suppose a pair of cameras with synchronized shots are used. I would like and appreciate very much to have your comments about this type of 3D shots with moving people or objects.
Please, take a look at http://www.flickr.com/photos/joserodmon/sets/72157603505323290/. Your comments will be very valuable to me.
Thank very much for your time and effort. Sorry for my poor English.
Best regards, Pepe
The Answer
Thank you for your question Pepe! First of all, your English is excellent.
Your confusion is entirely my fault. It is certainly true that subjects which move while taking 3D photos are problematic, but only if you are using a single camera to take two separate shots. The most accessible way to take 3D photos is using the cha-cha method, as I described in How to Take 3D Photos.
There are a number of other ways to take 3D photos that eliminate this problem by capturing both the left and right eye views at the same time. These include:
- A 3D lens or attachment, such as the Loreo 3D Lens in a Cap.
- A specialist 3D camera which has two lenses built in and records an image through both of them at the same time.
- A twin-camera system, which mounts two cameras side-by-side, and takes 3D photos by triggering the two cameras simultaneously.
For the 3D photos to which you refer, for example the one at the top of this post, I used my Loreo 3D Lens in a Cap. This used a mirror and dual-lens arrangement to capture left and right views simultaneously on a single exposure, thus allowing me to freeze movement.
I’m sorry I didn’t make it clearer that I take 3D photos using both methods. I will go back to the posts in question and make a note of the fact. I have updated all of my 3D images in Flickr so that they are tagged either “cha-cha” or “loreo” to specify what method I used to capture the image.
More Information
So what can you do if you want to capture 3D images of potentially moving subjects using the cha-cha method? Here are some suggestions:
- If shooting people, explain to them that remaining motionless is critical. Motionless includes breathing, where they are looking, shifting their weight, ANY movement.
- Be quick! Plan your shot and rehearse it in your head before you shoot, so you can get both shots withing a very short period. You increase your chances of capturing slow or infrequently moving subjects.
- Take the same pair of shots several times. You might be lucky and find a pair where movement is minimised
- If shooting plants outdoors, shoot on still days and wait for a lull in the wind. Small breezes will change lots of the smallest leaves, so calm weather will help a lot.
- Accept that some things are impossible. Any kind of moving water is impossible, windblown vegetation, people whom you are unable to instruct etc will likely be forever impossible with the cha-cha technique.
I probably overstated the problem of shooting cha-cha 3D photos of moving subjects, and a little practice and experimentation may open up new possibilities, but there will always be a limit.
Send in Your Own Question
If you have any questions about my photography, any of the posts or photography in general, please don’t hesitate to get in touch with me, either via the blog comments, email, or via the contact form that I’ve just decided needs to go on my Profile page (look for it soon!). If I think your question would make a suitable topic for a blog post, I’ll write one up and share the answer with blog readers.
Hope to hear from you soon!
PROJECT: 3D For Everyone
- At May 01, 2008
- By Neil Creek
- In Projects
31


Submissions are coming in – you can see them here.
3D is coming. Thousands of theatres around the USA are being converted into 3D cinemas, and the big names in Hollywood are getting behind the new medium, with Pixar, James Cameron and others saying they’ll never make a 2D movie again. With the coming wave of 3D movies, you can guarantee that the third dimension is going to be the hottest “new” thing again.
If you thought you needed expensive cameras or 3D lens attachments to get into 3D photography, I’ve got some good news for you. Anybody, with any kind of camera can take 3D photos using the “cha-cha” method. And that’s what May’s project is all about!
Subscribe now to stay up to date with project news and 3D tutorials!
Contents
3D For Everyone
In March, I showed you How to See 3D Photos, and then How to Take 3D Photos. If you haven’t read these posts yet, go and do so, they’re essential reading to participate in this project.
The task for this project is quite simple. Take a 3D photo of anything you like, using the cha-cha method, process the image into a single cross-view 3D image (as described in the linked post above) and submit it via the form below!
Due date: May 24th extended to May 26th
Rules
- This competition is open to anyone around the world.
- Images must be presented in crosseye format.
- Photos must be taken using the cha-cha method with a single camera. 3D cameras or lenses are not acceptable.
- You may use any photographic equipment you have, except a 3D lens or similar. Flash-lit, macro or other specialty 3D photography is encouraged.
- Images must meet the technical standards described below.
- The subject of the photo must be appropriate for a general audience. Implied artistic nudity is acceptable, but not more than that. The final decision about entry appropriateness is mine.
- The photo must be taken within the period of the project.
- Submissions will be displayed for voting anonymously. Do NOT watermark your image.
- I will be accepting ONE and only one entry per person, so pick your best shot.
- Competitors may change their mind and submit a different entry up until the due date. The most recently submitted entry will be considered the final entry.
- Upload the photo to your preferred photo sharing service or blog.
- All submissions must be on publicly accessible pages – no myspace or facebook accounts please.
- Flickr entries must allow access to “All Sizes”, otherwise I have to use a workaround to save the image.
- Submit your entry by filling out the form below.
- You agree to the Terms of Entry.
- The due date for your submission is the end of May 26th AEST – check here for the time in your zone.
- These rules may change at any stage during the project if I feel that it is necessary.
Note: Entrants may post links to their submissions in the comments below and ask specific questions about their photos (eg – how can I correct the window violation in this photo). This project is about learning how to take great 3D photos, so I’m happy to offer any technical help on specific problems. I will not offer creative opinions, and only specific questions will be addressed. Questions such as: “how can I make my photo better”, or “is this good enough to be entered” will not be answered. All contestants may do this with their proposed entries before submitting them if they wish.
As submissions will be anonymous for voting, the comments for this thread will be taken offline during the voting to minimise the chance of people deliberately seeking out their friends’ photos in order to vote for them.
Judging Criteria
Due to the technical nature of many aspects of this competition, I will be working closely with the judges, and advising them about what makes a technically good 3D photo. Some photos may potentially disqualify themselves immediately if they do not meet the technical requirements. The idea of the project is to explore the artistic merit of 3D photography, while ensuring a high standard of technical skill. The judges will be requested to make their choice based on the following criteria.
- 3D effect must be natural. Exaggerated or underdone 3D is not acceptable, but this will depend on the subject.
- Large scale “hyper-stereo” photos (eg: cityscape, landscape) are permitted.
- No part of the image may touch the 3D window edge (ie: window violation), except for the bottom, and then may not extend forward of that edge.
- Movement of the subject between frames should be avoided, and if it affects the 3D effect, will not be acceptable.
- Both elements of the 3D image must match, including white balance, exposure, etc.
- The image must have a suitable frame or border to make viewing comfortable, unless this isn’t relevant (eg: a macro 3D against a white field).
- Distracting reflections or specular highlights are discouraged. This is the case when the reflection is drastically different to each eye and looks out of place.
- Photos which display the 3D effect cleverly or creatively without being cliche are to be encouraged.
- Creative intrusions into the 3D window are encouraged, provided they meet all other technical requirements.
- Distracting background elements which appear only in one view are strongly discouraged.
- Images which display good photographic technique, beyond just good 3D technique are encouraged.
- ALL of these criteria are flexible. If a great image suffers from a minor flaw, it should still be considered a potential winner if the overall effect of the photo is good enough to render the flaw insignificant.
There may seem like a lot of rules and criteria, but due to the prizes, I’m expecting some pretty fierce competition, and I’d like to see the winning prize go to the best photo. I’d also like everyone to know up-front what the judges will be looking for, to give you all the best chance you have to win!
Prizes!

* Every person who submits an entry to this project will receive for FREE a Pixi 3D viewer, designed for viewing parallel 3D images on screen or in print about 25-33cm wide. The only condition for this gift is that everyone who receives a viewer please share their experience using it and any suggestions they have on this blog. I’ll be writing a post specifically for this purpose. Loreo will ship the viewer to the address you give in your submission, free of charge.

** The winner of the 3D for Everyone project will win a Loreo 3D Lens-in-a-Cap, plus a Deluxe 3D Viewer and Lite 3D Viewer. This will be shipped as a Mail Order Box Set. This lens must be used on an SLR camera, and you will need to provide Loreo (through me) with the make and model of your camera to ensure you get the correct lens. Some cameras will not accept the 3D Lens-in-a-Cap. Please check compatibility with your camera here. If you do not own an SLR or DSLR, then you will not be able to use the 3D lens, however you may want to give it as a gift, or if you are planning to buy a DSLR, get the appropriate 3D lens in anticipation.
The prizes for this competition are proudly provided by Loreo, a 3D Camera and Optical Systems company running since 1982. I am the happy owner of a Loreo 3D lens-in-a-cap for my Canon 350D, and when I had the idea to run a 3D photo project I thought Loreo would be a natural choice to be a sponsor and possibly offer a prize.
When I approached them, I offered them banner advertising throughout my blog for the month of the project, as well as an in-depth review of their product, and acknowledgement as the sponsors of the competition. I asked if they were willing to donate a 3D lens-in-a-cap as a prize for the winner. They responded to me enthusiastically, and happily offered the 3D lens as a prize. In return, they only asked for the acknowledgement and an honest review. They said that they don’t have a problem with getting enough people visiting their site as much as they do with people’s expectations of the product.
3D photography can be a tricky business, and the hype around 3D can lead to misconceptions. Add to that the technical issues of getting a single product to work on a wide variety of DSLR bodies, and you can understand that Loreo have their hands full educating their customers. They asked that I give an honest and thorough review of the 3D lens, so that anybody who might read the review and choose to buy the lens would be fully informed of its strengths and weaknesses.
I have been impressed by Loreo’s enthusiasm for their product, and for the amateur 3D photography community. The 3D lens-in-a-cap is a kind of half-way point between single camera cha-cha 3D photography, and high end 3D cameras, or dual camera setups. I am happy and proud to be working with them to help raise the profile of 3D photography.
3D Month
All month I’ll be writing posts on the topic of 3D. Look forward to a review of the Loreo 3D Lens-in-a-Cap, and the new Pixi 3D viewer. I’ll also try to go into a bit more detail on how to take and process great 3D photos to give entrants so more tips and pointers. I’ll also be scouring the net to find the best examples of 3D photography, and maybe even look at some of the news in the 3D world. So if you’re entering this project, or just want to know more about 3D photography, make sure you subscribe to my blog at the top right so you don’t miss anything!
If you have any questions about the rules or judging criteria, please leave a comment below.
Submit Your Entry
The submissions for this project have closed. You can see the photos submitted to the project here.
Terms & Conditions
Terms: Any photo that you submit remains your sole property. I (Neil Creek) make no claims of ownership or copyright. By submitting a link to your photo, you grant me the right to include a copy of the photo, or a thumbnail of the photo in future posts on the blog (Neil Creek – Photographer) for the purposes of conducting the project, or to be used as an illustrative example in other future blog posts, or for the promotion of this project elsewhere on the blog or on other sites not controlled by me. In all cases all photos displayed for any purpose will be properly attributed and links will be provided to the creator where possible. The exception to the attribution obligation is on the submissions and voting pages, where the images are displayed anonymously for the purpose of conducting a fair vote. You also agree to allow me to place advertising on pages on this blog where your photo appears for the purposes of promoting a prize sponsor, or general advertising on the site, without any compensation. Judges’ decisions are final. Prizes are not redeemable to cash or any other form. Neil Creek is not responsible for any problems that occur as a result of entering this competition, including but not limited to: eye strain or injury, damage to or loss of the prizes in transit, dissatisfaction with the prize, incompatibilities of the prize and your camera equipment. It is the winner’s responsibility to provide Loreo with accurate information about their camera for the purpose of being sent the appropriate 3D lens. All questions regarding the prizes themselves should be directed to loreo.com. The information collected as part of this project (including name, email, postal address etc) will be used only for the purposes of running the competition. This information will be provided to Loreo in order to send out the gifts and prize, but will not be retained by Loreo for any other purposes. Your information will never be sold or given to third parties. By clicking submit on the form above, you acknowledge that you have read, understand and agree to these terms.
Recent Comments